SHOP BY BRAND
sale sample society

Best Eye Pencils

  • Stila Cosmetics  Kajal Eye Pencil

  • Jane Iredale  Eye Pencil

  • diego dalla palma  Eye Pencil

    diego dalla palma Eye Pencil

    $19.50 - $29.00

    on orders $49+

  • Gorgeous Cosmetics  Eye Pencil

    Gorgeous Cosmetics Eye Pencil

    $17.50 - $22.00

    on orders $49+

  • Colorescience  Pro Eye Pencil

  • Jane Iredale  Eye Highlighter Pencil

  • Gorgeous Cosmetics  iINK Liquid Eye Pencil

  • Lord & Berry  Velluto Eye Shadow Pencil

  • Kevyn Aucoin  The Eye Pencil Primatif

  • diego dalla palma  Waterproof Eye Pencil

  • LORAC  Creamy Brow Pencil

  • Borghese  Eye Accento Pencil

    Borghese Eye Accento Pencil

    $20.50 - $21.00

    on orders $49+

  • Lord & Berry  Polish Eye Pencil

  • Vincent Longo  Duo Eye Pencil

    Vincent Longo Duo Eye Pencil

    $18.00 - $26.00

    on orders $49+

  • Antonym Cosmetics  Natural Eye Pencil

  • Lord & Berry  Paiettes Eye Pencil

  • Lord & Berry  Silk Kajal Eye Pencil

  • Lord & Berry  Line Shade Eye Pencil

  • Lord & Berry  Sketch Eye Pencil

Jane Iredale, LORAC, Stila Cosmetics - and 122 other brands make our Makeup selection extraordinary. You will consistently find that our prices are among the lowest in the industry. We do not yet offer guaranteed overnight shipping, although many areas of the country do receive their orders the next day. Note that some items, including those shipped directly from the manufacturer, will take longer to arrive; ship times for these products will be noted directly on the product detail page. We are committed to providing you with superior service and encourage you to contact our Customer Care team with any questions or concerns.