Cancel & Continue Shopping
Added to Cart close

Best Eyeliner

Top 10 best-selling products in Eyeliner as voted by BeautyBar.com Million-plus customer base

Ever wondered how to choose the best Eyeliner? Eyeliner, Mascara, Lash Enhancers - we have them all! We've got great prices too from $1 on Eyeliner and $2 on Mascara. There are about a million reasons to shop Beautybar.com. We offer free delivery on almost all orders. Our great customer service takes pride in delighting our customers.
1. Jane Iredale
Eye Pencil
Perfect Lines Flaunt perfectly lined eyes with Jane Iredale Eye Pencil. Made of natural pigments, this pencil delivers long-lasting color that stays put. Creamy and easy to apply, this pencil is so soft, it won't pull on the delicate skin around the eyes. Colored eye pencil Delivers long-lasting color Creamy and easy to apply Especially Suited For: All skin types Essential Elements: Eye Pencil is made with conditioning oils and waxes and colored with protective pigments. Free of: Synthetic dyesFor Best Effect: Best applied by taking color off with a brush. Then, flip the brush to smu
  • Read More
  • Front of the Line PRO Liquid Eyeliner
    2. Lorac
    Front of the Line PRO Waterproof Eyeliner
    Front and Center LORAC Front of the Line PRO Waterproof Eyeliner is a high-performing no-smudge, no-budge, water-resistant liquid liner. It boasts a unique automatic delivery system that provides a clean, precise application. From very fine to dramatically bold, this versatile pro will take you to the front of the line every time. Long-wearing, water resistant liquid liner Flexible tip helps with clean, precise applicationThe flexible tip provides ultimate control, accuracy and smooth strokes, so you'll never miss your lines. Especially Suited For: All skin types Essential Elements: A
  • Read More
  • 3. Sue Devitt
    Eye Intensifer Pencil
    Easy Gliding Sue Devitt's Eye Intensifier Pencil deepens your natural eye color with its rich shades and velvety texture. Formulated to lock in moisture, this eyeliner expands and contracts with facial movements without creasing, allowing for a long-lasting, effective look.  Deepens natural eye color Locks in moisture Long-lasting and crease-resistant application Especially Suited For: All skin types Essential Elements: Ceramide 2, hyaluronic filling spheres and nylon-12 anti-aging ingredients hold moisture and allow for crease-free facial movements. For Best
  • Read More
  • 4. Stila Cosmetics
    Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner
    Waterproof, Fade-Proof Eye Color You'll adore Stila Cosmetics Smudge Sticks for their vibrant color and staying power. These highly pigmented, waterproof eye liners deliver shimmer-intense shades to make eyes stand out.Long LastingWaterproofEasy to applySelf sharpening propel pencilShades:Stingray - BlackLionfish - Brown with ShimmerPurple tang - Purple with ShimmerMoray - Olive with ShimmerKoi - Metallic GoldSilver dollar - Metallic SilverPeacock - Cobalt BlueBlue ribbon - Navy GreyEspecially Suited For: Women who want apply-it and forget-it make-upEssential Elements: Volatile silicones and m
  • Read More
  • 5. Stila Cosmetics Stay All Day
    Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
    Liquid liner than stays put Stila Cosmetics Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner glides on with ease, won't smudge or run, and stays in place until you say when.  The thin marker-like tip is easy to use, even for beginners Delivers a defined thin line or a dramatic bold line with precision Goes on smoothly without skipping, smudging, or pulling Lasts all day! Especially Suited For: All skin types
    6. Stila Cosmetics
    Smudge Crayon Waterproof Primer + Shadow + Liner
    3-Benefits-In-1 Stila Smudge Crayon Waterproof Eye Primer + Shadow + Liner Dazzle is a 3-in-1 gel-based product that glides on with ease and stays in place until you say when. This creamy, multi-pearl formula is infused with emollients for a smooth, comfortable application. Stila Smudge Crayon Waterproof Eye Primer + Shadow + Line Dazzle also provides rich, bold color for more than 6 hours of continuous wear that wonÆt crease over time. The best part: ThereÆs a pull-out sharpener conveniently hidden in the base so your product can be ôon pointö no matter where you are. 3-in-1 product
  • Read More
  • Eye Liner 0.04 oz
    7. Jemma Kidd
    Define Stay-Put Eye Liner
    Runway-Ready EyesThis deep gray, long-lasting liner glides on easily. The pencil’s smooth tip adds definition and drama to the eyes, and the liner’s water- and smudge-proof finish ensures that it stays put. Its antioxidant-rich vitamin E formula conditions skin and helps protect against free radical damage, resulting in a healthier and more beautiful eye area. Each pencil features a pointed smudge tip for blurring and blending. Jemma Kidd’s line of Define Stay Put Eyeliners is one of the most long-lasting and smudge-proof liners available. It’s even been worn on the ru
  • Read More
  • 8. Jane Iredale
    Eye Highlighter Penci
    Instant Lift Wake up tired eyes with Jane Iredale Eye Highlighter Pencil. This jumbo pencil delivers an instant lift. Apply the white end to the inner ledge of the eye to make eyes look bigger and brighter. Using the pink side gives a soft, radiant effect. Two-sided jumbo eye highlighter pencil White end brightens and pink end softens Comes with its own sharpener Eye Highlighter Pencil comes with its own sharpener. Especially Suited For: All skin typesFor Best Effect: Use under the brows, around the inner corner of the eye or all over the eyelid.
    9. By Terry Crayon Khol Terrybly
    Multicare Eye Definer
    > Simply StunningWhether you are looking for a look that’s demure or dramatic, By Terry Crayon Kohl Terrybly Multicare Eye Definer creates stunning eyes. With its soft-tip and excellent glide-on action, this liner defines the contour of your eyes while applying intense matte and ultra-iridescent color. The waterproof formula guarantees a long-lasting, exceptionally precise line that can be applied as a kohl or eyeliner. Waterproof liner with intense matte and ultra-iridescent color Defines the contour of the eyes Long-lasting formulaCrayon Kohl Terrybly comes with a pencil sh
  • Read More
  • 10. Jane Iredale
    Mystikols
    Smoky Eye Effect A totally new kind of eyeliner and highlighter, Jane Iredale Mystikol creates definition around the eye for a soft, smoky eye effect. It has a creamy powder formula that won't fade, crease or smear. Hypoallergenic, dermatologist-tested and always formulated with exclusive skin care ingredients, Mystikol is safe for even the most sensitive eyes. Hypoallergenic eyeliner and highlighter Creates a soft, smoky eye effect Formula won't fade, crease or smear Especially Suited For: Sensitive eyesFor Best Effect: Apply the rich eyeliner and highlighter directly to the eye with the s
  • Read More